Using Incentives for Potty Training: Candy, Stickers & Toys
Rewards can work—when used correctly. The trick is rewarding effort (trying to use the potty) not just outcomes (successful pee). Small, immediate rewards beat big delayed ones. And you need an exit strategy before you start.
What the Research Shows
Studies on reward-based potty training show mixed results, but the patterns are clear:
- Small immediate rewards work better than big delayed rewards
- Verbal praise combined with tangible rewards beats either alone
- Rewards for "trying" reduce anxiety around accidents
- Phasing out rewards gradually prevents regression
Reward Options That Work
Sticker Charts
Best for: Visual kids who like tracking progress. Each try = one sticker. Fill a row = small prize.
Small Candy
Best for: Immediate motivation. One M&M or Skittle per successful try. Simple and effective.
Special Activities
Best for: Kids who aren't food-motivated. Extra story at bedtime, choosing dinner, 5 minutes of screen time.
Toy Rewards
Best for: Major milestones. Save these for "dry all day" or "used potty away from home" achievements.
🕐 Non-Food Motivation: Potty Watch
Some kids respond better to "game-ification" than treats. The Benny Bradley's Potty Training Watch makes potty time feel like a mission—vibrate reminder, try the potty, celebrate.
Common Mistakes
- Rewarding only success — Creates anxiety, increases accidents
- Rewards too big — Creates expectation problems
- No exit plan — Kid expects candy forever
- Inconsistency — Sometimes rewarding, sometimes not
Phasing Out Rewards
The goal is to make potty use intrinsic (they do it because it's normal, not for a treat). Here's how:
- Week 1-2: Reward every try
- Week 3-4: Reward successful tries only
- Week 5-6: Reward occasionally, emphasize verbal praise
- After: Phase out tangible rewards, keep celebrating
Related Guides
More From Parents Like You
Want the real talk from other moms? Visit our community site: